Using Evidence to Frame Problems of Practice

Keywords: problem of practice, evidence, framing, root cause analysis

Abstract

Improvement initiatives crafted based on well-understood problems of practice often stand the greatest chance of leading to sustainable educational improvements. Framing problems of practice using multiple modes of evidence is advisable to fully understand the system of root causes of the problem and its stakeholders. In this study, we used the document analysis method to investigate the types of evidence (e.g., literature, anecdotal, secondary data) that students used to frame problems of practice in EdD dissertations in practice within CPED consortium member institutions (N=53). Results suggest that students predominantly use literature to frame problems of practice with fewer using primary and secondary data. 

  

Author Biography

Lesley F. Leach, Tarleton State University

Lesley F. Leach serves as Professor in the Educational Leadership EdD program as well as Associate Dean for Research at Tarleton State University. She also serves as the CPED delegate for the university.

References

References

*References marked with an asterisk indicate studies included in the meta-analysis.

*Alencastro, M. (2015). E Ho ‘oulu ‘la nᾱ kumu mauli ola hawai’i: Preparing Hawaiian cultural identity teachers. Retrieved from https://www.cpedinitiative.org/assets/resource-center/docs/makalapua_ alencastre-alenc.pdf

*Altman, M. R., & Pizano, A. C. (2016). Quality in early care and education: Multiple perspectives and critical considerations for professional development in a diverse context. Retrieved from https://search-proquest-com.zeus.tarleton.edu/docview/1847567976/A6F3783D431F442APQ/1?accountid=7078

Archbald, D. (2014). The GAPPSI method: Problem-solving, planning and communicating. NCPEA Publishing.

Arendt, H. (1951). The origins of totalitarianism. New York: Houghton Mifflin Harcourt Publishing.

*Azziz, R. (2017). The nature of bias and its impact on disparate outcomes. Retrieved from https://www.cpedinitiative.org/assets/resource-center/docs/azziz_full_dip.pdf

*Baete, G., Burks, J., & Pollio, M. (2012). Bringing urban high school reform to scale: Rapidly moving dramatic numbers of student to proficient performance. Retrieved from https://www.cpedinitiative.org/assets/resource-center/docs/louisville_burks_baete_polli.pdf

Belzer, A., & Ryan, S. (2013). Defining the problem of practice dissertation: Where’s the practice, what’s the problem?. Planning and Changing, 44(3/4), 195-207.

*Benedict, C. M. (2014). Professional learning community: Increasing efficacy for student success. Retrieved from https://www.cpedinitiative.org/assets/resource-center/docs/benedict.pdf

*Boeding, B. (2017). Supporting the camouflaged in transition: Serving student veterans with disabilities. Retrieved from https://www.cpedinitiative.org/assets/resource-center/docs/boeding_full_dip.pdf

Booth, W. C., Colomb, G. G., Williams, J. M., Bizup, J., & Fitzgerald, W. (2016). The craft of research (4th ed.). Chicago, IL: The University of Chicago Press.

Bowen, G. A. (2009). Document analysis as a qualitative research methods. Qualitative Research Journal, 9(2), 27-40.

*Brown, R. (2013). Equity for students of color through practitioner accountability. Retrieved from https://www.cpedinitiative.org/assets/resource-center/docs/brown.pdf

Bryk, A. S., Gomez, L. M., Grunow, A., & LeMahieu, P. G. (2015). Learning to improve: How America’s schools can get better at getting better. Cambridge, MA: Harvard Education Press.

*Burke, A. (2012). From policy to practice: Implementing “move on when ready” at the local level in Arizona. Retrieved from https://www.cpedinitiative.org/assets/resource-center/docs/burke_dip.pdf

*Burt, T. D. (2014). From mission to measurement: Advancing postsecondary academic advising assessment and practice through evaluating program theory and outcomes. Retrieved from https://www.cpedinitiative.org/assets/resource-center/docs/burt.pdf

*Canelake, C. (2012). Implementing a standards-based teacher evaluation system: Learning experiences for administrators in an urban school district. Retrieved from https://www.cpedinitiative.org/assets/resource-center/docs/canelake_dip.pdf

Carnegie Project on the Education Doctorate. (n.d.-a) About CPED. Retrieved from https://www.cpedinitiative.org/page/AboutUs

Carnegie Project on the Education Doctorate. (n.d.-b). Database of Dissertations in Practice from CPED-Influenced EdD Programs. Retrieved from http://cpedinitiative.org/resource-library/dissertations

Carnegie Project on the Education Doctorate. (n.d.-c). CPED framework. Retrieved from https://cdn.ymaws.com/www.cpedinitiative.org/resource/resmgr/images/general_images/cped_infographic_5.png

*Cato, M. (2013). Nursing students anxiety in simulation settings: A mixed methods study. Retrieved from https://www.cpedinitiative.org/assets/resource-center/docs/cato.pdf

*Chalkley, J., Lyles, T., & Stacy, J. (2012). Statewide communities of practice for excellence: A statewide program evaluation. Retrieved from https://www.cpedinitiative.org/assets/resource-center/docs/vcu_stacy.chalkley.lyles.pdf

*Cicchino, M. (2014). Using game-based learning to foster critical thinking in student discourse. Retrieved from https://www.cpedinitiative.org/assets/resource-center/docs/cicchino.pdf

*Claravall, E. B. (2014). Creating and sustaining classroom knowledge through teacher research: Morphology as design intervention for struggling learners. Retrieved from https://www.cpedinitiative.org/assets/resource-center/docs/claravall.pdf

*Conlon, S., Gallagher, T., & Hooper, S. (2012). The unrealized constructs of school reform. Retrieved from https://www.cpedinitiative.org/assets/resource-center/docs/louisville_gallagher.conlon.pdf

*Cooper, D. W. (2014). Exploring embedded remediation for community college career technical education pathways: Promising practices. Retrieved from https://www.cpedinitiative.org/assets/resource-center/docs/cooper.pdf

Copland, M. A. (2000). Problem-based learning and prospective principals’ problem-framing ability. Educational Administration Quarterly, 36(4), 585-607.

*Creasia, C. R. (2014). The dynamics of instructional leadership & organizational structure in high performing urban schools. Retrieved from https://www.cpedinitiative.org/assets/resource-center/docs/creasia.pdf

*Diaz, C. S., Strang, M. L., Unger, A. L., & Van’t Hof, S. G. (2017). Utilizing the design thinking process to aid educators in their response to childhood lead exposure. Retrieved from https://www.cpedinitiative.org/assets/resource-center/docs/diaz_strang_unger_and_vant.pdf

*Eckerson, J. (2016). Teacher perspective on professional development needs for better serving Nebraska’s Spanish heritage language learners, Retrieved from https://www.cpedinitiative.org/assets/resource-center/docs/eckerson_dissertation.pdf

Gillham, J. C., Williams, N. V., Rife, G., & Parker, K. K. (2019). Problems of practice: A document analysis of education doctorate dissertations. Impacting Education: Journal on Transforming Professional Practice, 4(1), 1-9.

*Gonzalez, A. (2014). Using funds of knowledge to build trust between a teacher and parents of language-delayed preschoolers. Retrieved from https://www.cpedinitiative.org/assets/resource-center/docs/quintero_gonzalez.pdf

*Guan, Y. (2014). The effects of explicit listening strategy instruction on the listening comprehension of English as a second language (ESL) community college students. Retrieved from https://www.cpedinitiative.org/assets/resource-center/docs/guan.pdf

*Hall, R. A. (2014). Challenges on the road to school success for low socioeconomic and minority student: Dropout prevention and parent involvement. Retrieved from https://www.cpedinitiative.org/assets/resource-center/docs/hall.pdf

*Hanchi, N. M. (2013). A study of the implementation of the Ed.D. in educational leadership at the University of Central Florida 2010-2013: A profession. Retrieved from https://www.cpedinitiative.org/assets/resource-center/docs/marsh.pdf

*Hendron, J., Tolliver, S., Kim, A., & Deloatch, D. (2014). Ubiquitous computing in schools: A multi-case study of 1:1 districts. Retrieved from https://www.cpedinitiative.org/assets/resource-center/docs/hendron_et_ al.pdf

*Henriquez, A. (2013). “I hope to be a symbol of encouragement”: Using craft in community colleges to facilitate student voice in the remedial studies debate. Retrieved from https://www.cpedinitiative.org/page/DiPDatabase [link changed after data collection and was not retrievable].

*Jaggers, A., & Royster, P. (2012). Putting time on your side: A system for getting all students on a college ready trajectory. Retrieved from https://www.cpedinitiative.org/assets/resource-center/docs/louisville_royster.jaggers.pdf

*Jakubik, T. L. (2014). Graphic novels and the common core. Retrieved from https://www.cpedinitiative.org/assets/resource-center/docs/jakubik.pdf

Jonassen, D. H. (2000). Toward a design theory of problem solving. Educational Technology Research and Development, 48(4), 63-85.

*Kirchner, J. (2014). Student experiences of the community college developmental writing classroom. Retrieved from https://www.cpedinitiative.org/assets/resource-center/docs/kirchner.pdf

*Kline, N. C. (2014). The nature and degree of the relationship between chronic absenteeism and student achievement in a large metropolitan school district in Florida. Retrieved from https://search-proquest-com.zeus.tarleton.edu/docview/1860239472/F52238B2E5F247D8PQ/1?accountid=7078

*Kobett, B. M. (2016). A university-led beginning teacher mathematics community. Retrieved from https://www.cpedinitiative.org/assets/resource-center/docs/kobett_dissertation.pdf

*Larson, J. L. (2013). Secondary mathematics teachers’ literacy professional learning: An amalgamation of adolescent literacy, mathematics teaching and adult learning. Retrieved from https://www.cpedinitiative.org/assets/resource-center/docs/larson.pdf

Lewis, C. (2015). What is improvement science? Do we need it in education? Educational Researcher, 44(1), 54-61. Retrieved from https://www.emmausseries2.org/uploads/2/0/5/2/20520752/lewis_2015.pdf

*Louis, T. (2014). Design and implementation plan for the “I am potential” financial literacy education program. Retrieved from https://www.cpedinitiative.org/assets/resource-center/docs/louis.pdf

Ma, V. W., Dana, N. F., Adams, A., & Kennedy, B. L. (2018). Understanding the problem of practice: An analysis of professional practice EdD dissertations. Impacting Education: Journal on Transforming Professional Practice, 3, 13-22.

*Mataczynski, L. (2013). Advising and acculturation variables as predictors or sanctification, sense of belongings, and persistence among international undergraduates. Retrieved from https://www.cpedinitiative.org/assets/resource-center/docs/mataczynski.pdf

*Maltby, B., Richardson, D., Koontz, J., & Bhagat, R. (2014). A regional approach to school diversity: The possibility, feasibility, and desirability. Retrieved from https://www.cpedinitiative.org/assets/resource-center/docs/maltby_et_al.pdf

Mintrop, R. (2016). Design-based school improvement: A practical guide for education leaders. Cambridge, MA: Harvard Education Press.

*Morrison, C. (2015). Co-constructing college-going capital in a rural high school English class. Retrieved from https://www.cpedinitiative.org/assets/resource-center/docs/carissa_morrison-morrison.pdf

*Mostofo, J. (2013). Using lesson study with preservice secondary mathematics teachers: Effects on instruction, planning and efficacy to teach mathematics. Retrieved from https://www.cpedinitiative.org/assets/resource-center/docs/mostofo.pdf

*Muser, H. (2017). A parent’s dream come true: A study of adult students who are parents and their academic engagement in high education. Retrieved from https://www.cpedinitiative.org/assets/resource-center/docs/muser_full_dip.pdf

*Olsen, B. D. (2016). Preservice and practicing teacher science inquiry projects: An analysis of their understanding of the inquiry process. Retrieved from https://www.cpedinitiative.org/assets/resource-center/docs/olsen.benjamin_fulldip.pdf

Oxford Languages. (n.d.) Retrieved from https://en.oxforddictionaries.com/word-of-the-year/word-of-the-year-2016

*Palmer, R. (2014). Exploring online community among rural medical education students: A case study. Retrieved from https://www.cpedinitiative.org/assets/resource-center/docs/cped_award_presentation.pdf

*Paredes, M. C. (2012). Parent involvement as an instructional strategy: Academic parent-teacher teams. Retrieved from https://www.cpedinitiative.org/assets/resource-center/docs/paredes.pdf

*Patel, A. (2014). An evaluation study of Ravenswood’s youth transitioning to and through high school. Retrieved from https://www.cpedinitiative.org/assets/resource-center/docs/patel.pdf

Perry, J. A. (2013). Carnegie project on the education doctorate: The education doctorate-degree for our time. Planning and Changing, 44(3/4), 113-126. Retrieved from https://www.researchgate.net/publication/272148530_The_Education_Doctorate-_A_degree_for_our_times

Perry, J. A., & Imig, D. G. (2016). What do we mean by impact? Impacting Education, 1. Retrieved from https://impactinged.pitt.edu/ojs/index.php/ImpactingEd/article/view/26/12

*Philadelphia, M. (2013). Will schoolbased online faculty development be an effective tool for their professional growth. Retrieved from https://www.cpedinitiative.org/assets/resource-center/docs/philadelphia.pdf

*Rivera, N. (2013). Cooperative learning in a community college setting: Developmental coursework in mathematics. Retrieved from https://www.cpedinitiative.org/assets/resource-center/docs/rivera.pdf

*Riva, S. (2013). Deconstructing persistence in academic language among second-generation Latinos: How do second-generation Latino language minority community students alter their academic trajectories. Retrieved from https://www.cpedinitiative.org/assets/resource-center/docs/de_la_riva.pdf

Rohanna, K. (2017). Breaking the “adopt, attack, abandon” cycle: A case for improvement science in K-12 education. In C.A. Christie, M. Inkelas, & S. Lemire (Eds.), Improvement Science in Evaluation: Methods and Uses. New Directions for Evaluation, 153, 65-77. https://doi.org/10.1002/ev.20233

*Rose, D. (2013). Enrollment decisions of the underrepresented: Recruiting and college choice at military institutions. Retrieved from https://www.cpedinitiative.org/assets/resource-center/docs/rose.pdf

*Ruggles, T. (2012). Masters level graduate student writing groups: Exploring academic identity. Retrieved from https://search-proquest-com.zeus.tarleton.edu/docview/1010624372/2865932CF61B44D4PQ/1?accountid=7078

Schön, D. (1983). The reflective practitioner. New York: Basic Books.

Schön, D. A., & Rein, M. (1995). Frame reflection: Toward the resolution of intractable policy controversies. New York: Basic Books.

*Schwarting, J. (2014). Influencing social capital in times of change: A three pronged approach to instructional coaching at the middle school level. Retrieved from https://www.cpedinitiative.org/assets/resource-center/docs/schwarting.pdf

*Spilde, A. (2013). Mathematics in a second grade classroom: The effects of cognitively guided problem solving. Retrieved from https://www.cpedinitiative.org/assets/resource-center/docs/spilde.pdf

Storey, V. A., Caskey, M. M., Hesbol, K. A., Marshall, J. E., & Maughan, B. D. (2015). Examining EdD dissertations in practice: The Carnegie Project on the Education Doctorate. International HETL Review, 5(2).

Timperley, H. S., & Robinson, V. M. J. (1998). Collegiality in schools: Its nature and implications for problem solving. Educational Administration Quarterly, 34, 608-629.

*Veith, V. (2013). Algebra for all and its relationship to English language learner’s opportunity-to-learn. Retrieved from https://www.cpedinitiative.org/assets/resource-center/docs/veith.pdf

*Walker, A. (2017). Transformative school leadership: A qualitative examination of school leaders’ sensemaking of lived racial experiences and racial inequities in education. Retrieved from https://cdn.ymaws.com/www.cpedinitiative.org/resource/resmgr/docs/DiPs/Walker_Full_DiP.pdf

*Walker, J. (2016). Brain-targeted early childhood beginnings: A case study in India brain-targeted early childhood beginnings: a case study in India. Retrieved from https://www.cpedinitiative.org/assets/resource-center/docs/cped_jimmie_walker_dissertat.pdf

*Wallace, W. (2013). California accountability policy and intensification: A quantitative study of teachers’ perceptions. Retrieved from https://search-proquest-com.zeus.tarleton.edu/docview/1015179413/DAE44916583E49E2PQ/1?accountid=7078

*Yavuz, O. (2014). Improving college readiness, pursuit, access, and persistence of disadvantaged students. Retrieved from https://www.cpedinitiative.org/assets/resource-center/docs/yavuz.pdf

Published
2021-10-19
How to Cite
Leach, L. F., Baker, C., Leamons, C. G., Bunch, P., & Brock, J. (2021). Using Evidence to Frame Problems of Practice. Impacting Education: Journal on Transforming Professional Practice, 6(4), 1–7. https://doi.org/10.5195/ie.2021.144
Section
Research Articles